Juicy and Flavorful Grilled Chicken Caprese Sandwich

Brining chicken breasts is the secret to the most flavorful chicken sandwiches, including this homemade grilled chicken caprese sandwich! A quick 30-minute brine ensures the grilled chicken breast comes out juicy and flavorful every time. Serve with ciabatta bread, fresh mozzarella, roasted tomatoes, and pesto aioli for the ultimate chicken caprese sandwich.

two white plates with grilled chicken sandwiches cut in half on a blue and green plaid napkin

When treated with the chance to go to lunch with girlfriends, I beeline for the sandwich section of the menu. Sure, I could go with a good salad recipe (hellooooo Italian Chopped Salad) but something like this juicy and flavorful grilled chicken sandwich would totally catch my eye —that’s because easy and approachable Italian recipes are my jam.

Pair it with my Tomato Bisque for the perfect cold weather lunch with some girlfriends, post-shopping expedition, of course.

So—let’ start…how do you make a juicy grilled chicken breast?

Brine, my friend, brine.

Why brine chicken breasts?

One word: juiciness.

a white bowl of raw chicken in a brine and a wooden bowl of salt

If the word “brine” conjures up scary thoughts of a huge turkey in a cooler swimming in seasoned water, let me put your mind at ease. Brined grilled chicken breasts will always be juicy and flavorful.

And it only takes two ingredients.

Salt and water.

What kind of salt for brining?

The best kind of salt for brining is kosher salt. You can of course use table salt or sea salt but make sure to check the size of the crystals. Bon Appetit offers more info on the differences between types of salt. For this recipe, now is not the time to bring out your expensive, flaky Maldon sea salt. Save that for putting in a cute little container on your table for sprinkling over my Italian Arugula Salad (which is sooo good on top of this sandwich).

Best cut of chicken to use in a sandwich

Whole chicken breast on a piece of parchment.

Chicken breasts are the best to use in a sandwich because they:

  • are approximately the same size as a bun (assuming you don’t get chicken breasts that are really supersized)
  • look really good when cut in a sandwich
  • cook easily on the grill, especially when pounded to be of even thickness

How to brine chicken breasts (plus how long!)

A brine should be cold as you don’t want to cook or poach the chicken. A good brine ratio is:


Chicken Breast Brine Ratio

2 cups of cold water : 2 tablespoons of salt

-Josie + Nina

30 minute brining steps:

  • Stir the brine until all the salt is dissolved.
  • Place your trimmed chicken breasts in the brine.
  • Refrigerate for 30 minutes.
  • After the allotted time, remove the chicken breasts and rinse them.
  • Pat dry the chicken breasts with paper towels before seasoning with salt and roasted garlic powder.
  • Keep an eye on the time. You don’t want to over-brine chicken breasts or it will turn spongy and mushy mushy.

What is caprese? (and how do you pronounce it?)


Repeat after me: “ka-pray-zay“!

Caprese is thought to have originated in Capri and if you’re like me, you’re grateful every summer when basil and tomatoes are at their best. Caprese is four layers:

  • Basil
  • Tomato
  • Fresh mozzarella (preferably)
  • Olive oil (preferably Italian…but feel free to use your favorite!)

What kind of tomatoes for caprese?

fresh garden tomato on a white background with loose basil leaves and more tomatoes in a white basket

The best kind of tomatoes for caprese are

  • firm
  • ripe
  • bright red
  • juicy

Summer tomatoes are a clear choice and if you can go to a farmer’s market or pick them from your own garden, even better! Campari tomatoes from Costco or heirloom or vine-ripened tomatoes from the grocery store work really well as do Romas.

Basil and fresh mozzarella are pretty easy to get year round but what’s a girl to do when you have a hankering for a good caprese salad or sandwich in the winter? And the tomatoes aren’t gorgeous?

Chill out. And get roasting.

This post contains links to affiliate websites including Amazon. I make a small commission for any purchases made using these links. Thank you!

Slow roasting tomatoes

a baking sheet with sliced roasted tomatoes and a wooden bowl of salt

Most any mediocre tomato can be cajoled into sweet flavor by using a little heat. Slow roasting tomatoes is a technique that transforms a mealy tomato into a flavor-bomb.

Tomato Roasting Tips

For roasting, you can use any kind of tomato you have on hand. Roma, cherry, grape, heirloom. If they’re already in small bites like a cherry or grape, leave them as is. If you’re using a larger tomato, thickly slice them.

Drizzle them with olive oil and season with kosher salt.

The key is using low heat and roasting them sloooowly. Like 300 for two hours. Roast them on Sunday and you’ll have them all week for sandwiches, puree into soup or use in tomato sauce.

Make the pesto aioli

a white bowl with pesto aioli on a wooden tray and blue and green plaid napkin

Aioli is traditionally a blend of lemon, oil, garlic, mustard, and egg but we’re making a cheater aioli. Start with mayo and some Greek yogurt, add a big dollop of store-bought pesto (which also has garlic and the oil) and finish it all off with a squeeze of lemon. Easy!

p.s. my favorite store-bought pesto is from Costco. You can’t beat the price or the flavor.

Tips for grilling chicken

a baking sheet with seasoned raw chicken on a paper towel with a wooden bowl of salt and spoon of garlic powder
  • Heat a gas or charcoal grill to approximately 400 degrees (or when coals are ash white).
  • Season the chicken breasts with a little pepper and garlic powder (you don’t really need more salt at this point because of the brine).
  • Grill the chicken breasts for approximately 4 minutes on each side or until an internal temperature of 165° is reached (use a reliable meat thermometer – no guessing!)

Assemble the caprese sandwich

a white plate with an open-faced grilled chicken sandwich on a blue and green plaid napkin

Drizzle a little olive oil on the inside of the split ciabatta bun. Place on the grill during the last minute of grilling. (Or turn off the grill completely and toast the buns for a couple of minutes)

Spread the aioli on each side of the grilled bread.

On the top half of the bun, layer on:

  • slow roasted tomatoes.
  • fresh mozzarella slices
  • arugula
  • finish with a drizzle of balsamic glaze

Serving suggestions

a white plate with a grilled chicken sandwich on a blue and green plaid napkin

For a crew: Slice the chicken thinly and use small crostini to make open faced versions of this sandwich. Top with a dollop or using a pastry bag, a rosette of aioli for a pretty party appetizer.

For a few: The best thing about this grilled chicken sandwich is you can make it for as many people as you’re serving.

For a single serving:  use 1 Roma tomato per person, ½ heirloom or 5 cherry tomatoes

Storage, make ahead and reheating

  • Store any leftovers in a food safe container and refrigerate for up to 3 days in the fridge.
  • Make ahead by brining and grilling the chicken earlier in the day, refrigerate until ready to assemble and serve the sandwiches at room temperature.

What to serve with a grilled caprese sandwich

a white plate with a grilled chicken sandwich on a blue and green plaid napkin.
4.80 from 5 votes

Juicy and Flavorful Grilled Chicken Caprese Sandwich

Brining chicken breasts is the secret to the most flavorful chicken sandwiches, including this homemade grilled chicken caprese sandwich! A quick 30-minute brine ensures the grilled chicken breast comes out juicy and flavorful every time. Serve with ciabatta bread, fresh mozzarella, roasted tomatoes, and pesto aioli for the ultimate chicken caprese sandwich 
Prep Time:30 minutes
Cook Time:10 minutes
Tomato Roasting:2 hours
Total Time:2 hours 40 minutes
Servings 4

Ingredients
 

For the Chicken

For the Pesto Aioli

For the Roasted Tomatoes

Toppings and Bun

  • 4 ciabatta buns, sliced in half and lightly toasted
  • ½ lb fresh mozzarella , sliced
  • 4 oz. arugula, washed and dried
  • balsamic glaze, see Notes

Instructions

For the chicken

  • In a large bowl, add salt to the cold water and stir until the salt is dissolved, about 2 minutes.
  • Add the chicken breasts. Cover with a lid or plastic wrap and refrigerate for 30 minutes.
  • After 30 minutes, remove the chicken and rinse under cold water. Pat completely dry.
  • Season both sides of the chicken with ground black pepper and garlic powder.

Make the aioli

  • While the chicken is brining, combine the mayonnaise, pesto and lemon in a small bowl and set aside. Taste for seasoning. Add a little salt, if needed. Cover and refrigerate.

Grill the Chicken

  • Heat a gas grill to 400°. LIghtly oil the grates using an olive oil dipped paper towel.
  • Place the chicken on the grill and cook for approximately 4-5 minutes on each side, or until a meat thermometer registers 165°.
  • Drizzle some oil on the insides of the split ciabatta rolls. Grill cut side down during the last minute or so of the chicken cooking over indirect heat or an upper level of your grill if you have one. You can also turn off the grill to toast the bread after the chicken has finished cooking.

To slow roast the tomatoes

  • Preheat the oven to 300°
  • Place the sliced tomatoes on a baking sheet. Don't crowd the tomatoes.
  • Drizzle with olive oil and a healthy sprinkle of salt and black pepper.
  • Roast for approximately 2 hours until the tomatoes are rich in color and smell.

Assemble the sandwich

  • Place 1-2 tablespoons of aioli on both sides of a ciabatta roll.
  • Top with the grilled chicken followed by the fresh mozzarella, roasted tomatoes, a sprinkling of arugula and a drizzle of balsamic glaze.
  • Close up the sandwich. Slice in half and serve.

Notes

For large chicken breasts:
  • If your chicken breasts are really thick, they’ll take longer to cook. Feel free to pound them thinner with a rolling pin or meat tenderizer and cut them in half to fit on your roll easier.
Roasting Tomato Info:
  • as an alternative, you can use jarred sun dried tomatoes
  • For a single serving:  use 1 Roma tomato per person, ½ heirloom or 5 cherry tomatoes.
For a party appetizer: Slice the chicken thinly and use small crostini to make open faced versions of this sandwich. Top with a dollop or using a pastry bag, a rosette of aioli for a pretty party appetizer.
Balsamic glaze info: Costco has it sometimes but Colavita’s is great too.
Course: Appetizer, Dinner, Lunch
Cuisine: Grilling
Author: Lori Murphy
Did you make this recipe? Tag @josieandnina or tag #josieandnina!

Leave a Comment or Ask A Question

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

3 Comments

  1. Delicious, truly a flavor bomb! This is the first I’ve roasted tomatoes and they were awesome, a must do again!! Thanks Lori5 stars