2-Minute Fresh Basil & Walnut Pesto Sauce

Pesto without pine nuts is still pesto! You won’t miss the pine nuts with this super quick and easy walnut basil pesto. Toss it with warm bow tie pasta or spread it on crostini for a yummy bruschetta base. Inspired by my oh-so-simple 2 minute classic pesto recipe.

a wooden board with basil, parmesan cheese and a knife near a bowl of walnuts, olive oil bottle and garlic.
You won’t miss the pine nuts in this walnut basil pesto.

A classic basil pesto, one of the simplest homemade pasta sauce recipes to make, is made with pine nuts. But let’s face it—not everybody can or wants to buy pine nuts.

“Pine nuts are dear,” Grandma Nina used to say. (Dear was a word she used often to describe something that was expensive.) She’s right and that’s why this extra creamy pistachio pesto sauce is made without pine nuts.

And now we are calling on walnuts. You’re going to be nuts about how good they taste in this homemade pesto pasta sauce!

Ooof…couldn’t resist.

This post contains links to affiliate websites including Amazon. I make a small commission for any purchases made using these links. Thank you!

Swap the pine nuts for walnuts in pesto

open food processor with basil and nuts for pesto without pine nuts
Homemade pesto pasta sauce needs only a few simple ingredients.

Pesto already has so few ingredients with the nuts being the most flexible ingredient of all. We are substituting walnuts for the pine nuts with creamy and just-as-delicious results.

Here’s what you need to make this walnut pesto recipe:

Fresh basil leaves. Whether from your garden or in an herb packet from the grocery store, fresh basil leaves are paramount to pesto. Of course you can use different greens like spinach or arugula, but we are making classic pesto and for that we need basil.

Fresh garlic cloves. Just 1 or 2 add a nice little bite. The traditional recipe for pesto alla Genovese doesn’t usually have garlic but when has that stopped us?

Extra virgin olive oil. I know choosing olive oil can be subjective because some definitely have more grassy notes and others more fruity notes.

There’s a lot going on flavor-wise so the mildest flavored extra-virgin olive oil is suggested. Extra-virgin olive oil is olive oil that has been cold-pressed instead of being heated and refined.

Walnuts. I use the toasted walnut halves or pieces like the ones sold at Trader Joe’s but you can also dry toast walnuts in a skillet.

Parmesan and/or Romano cheese. I say “and/or” because we are going to use both. You don’t have to if you only have one or the other on hand but each adds its own flavor texture (Parmesan is more crystal-like) and flavor profile (Romano has a saltier flavor).

Unsalted butter. Marcella’s secret and adds so much luxurious flavor to pesto.

Equipment needed to make pesto

The word “pesto” in Italian means “to pound or crush”

You have plenty of options, some mechanical and some not, to pound out some basil pesto recipe.

Food processor

A food processor like the Magimix food processor is a great countertop appliance to make a simple and really creamy pesto with walnuts.

Mortar and pestle

While you could use a molcajete, a marble mortar and pestle is truly the classic way to make a homemade pesto pasta sauce. Pesto made with a mortar and pestle is creamier in texture but the downside is that it takes longer than the food processor method.

Blender

Similar to a food processor, a blender can also be used to make pesto. Don’t overblend or your pesto will end up bitter! A high speed blender, like a Vitamix, can heat your pesto, pulse blend the pesto to your desired texture.

p.s. this is the Vitamix model I own.

Hand chopping

You can finely chop the basil and pesto ingredients by hand using either a knife or a mezzaluna. Put on some music and grab a drink. It will take a little longer and there will be more texture to the pesto.

Options…they’re a good thing!

How to make walnut basil pesto

Chopped walnuts in sauce pan to be toasted for pesto without pine nuts
Toast and chop walnuts, if needed.
processed pesto in food processor with spoon
Pulse processor 5 times before adding in extra virgin olive oil
mason jar with pesto and a brass spoon on top
Finished pesto ready for pasta, salad dressing or crostini.
  • Chop the walnuts and toast, if needed, in a dry skillet.
  • Add the fresh basil leaves to the large bowl of a food processor. The one here is 14 cups. Layer in the cheese, whole garlic cloves, and nuts.
  • Pulse the processor 5-7 times. No more, no less!
  • Slowly pour in the oil through the chute while running the processor to get the desired texture.
  • Remove the blade and scrape the pesto into a bowl.
  • Use the end of a wooden spoon or a pastry blender and press the butter and cheese into the pesto by hand (image a couple of scrolls up) until creamy and mixed in.

What other kinds of nuts work in pesto?

  • Sunflower seeds. Toasted sunflower seeds are a readily available ingredient and one that is so good in this pepper jack cheese dip.
  • Pumpkin seeds
  • Pistachios
  • Hazelnuts
  • Macadamia nuts

How to Toast Walnuts

To toast walnuts, add them to a dry skillet heated over medium hit for approximately 2-3 minutes. Keep an eye on them so they don’t burn (if they do, you’ll have to start over or your pesto will not taste good).

A borrowed technique for the best walnut pesto

white bowl on a wooden board with pesto and two pats of butter, grated parmesan and a muddler
Mixing in butter and parmesan by hand makes a rich and creamy walnut pesto recipe

This technique from the queen of Italian cooking, Marcella Hazan, makes such an amazingly rich pesto. (Btw, her best-selling cookbook, Essentials of Italian Cooking, is the perfect gift for the aspiring Italian cook.)

Marcella uses both the food processor and mixes the pesto by hand for this technique. Here’s what you’ll do:

  • Quickly pulse the ingredients basil, garlic, walnuts and cheese in a food processor which eliminates the need to chop the basil.
  • Muddle in a bit of butter and a second cheese (parmesan) by hand, adding a rich creamy texture to the pesto.

Where to use pesto

walnut pesto on a deli sandwich in a gingham basket
Pressed Italian Sandwich
three pieces of flatbread with walnut pesto, red onions, roasted red peppers, chicken and cheese
Chicken Pesto Flatbread

Homemade pesto without walnuts is the best base for a pressed Italian sandwich great for a tailgate party!

And spread a little pesto onto a flatbread before topping with chicken, cheese and onions for an amazing chicken pesto flatbread that makes a super simple and light dinner recipe.


How to Keep Pesto from Turning Black

Pesto doesn’t like two things: heat or air. Just like basil leaves, pesto will turn black if heated directly or exposed to the air for too long. Quickly cover pesto once it’s blended or use it immediately!


Storage suggestions and other good stuff

  • Refrigerate in an airtight container up to 4 days. Stir periodically to keep the oil from separating.
  • Freeze. Fill your favorite silicone ice cube trays or these awesome 1/2 cup Souper Cubes and make a couple of batches of pesto and you’ll have fresh pesto for the coming winter. Freeze pesto in an airtight container or freezer safe bags/containers up to 6 months. Defrost completely in the fridge before using.

Made this recipe?

I’d love it if you’d share your review and leave a star rating and comment!


a wooden board with basil, parmesan cheese and a knife near a bowl of walnuts, olive oil bottle and garlic.
5 from 1 vote

2-Minute Fresh Basil & Walnut Pesto Sauce

Pesto without pine nuts is still pesto! You won't miss the pine nuts with this super quick and easy walnut basil pesto. Toss it with warm bow tie pasta or spread it on crostini for a yummy bruschetta base. Inspired by my oh-so-simple 2 minute classic pesto recipe.
Prep Time:2 minutes
Total Time:2 minutes
Servings 1 cup

Equipment

Ingredients
 

Instructions

  • Place the basil, salt, pepper, whole cloves of garlic and walnuts in the medium sized bowl of a food processor or mini prep. Pulse about 5-7 times to chop the basil and garlic. Then, turn the machine on and pour the oil in slowly through the feed tube at the top. Stop when you have a thick sauce, about 30 seconds or so.
    3 cups basil leaves, 1-2 teaspoons kosher salt, garlic, ½ teaspoon ground black pepper, 3 Tablespoons toasted walnuts, ½ cup olive oil
  • Remove the pesto to a medium bowl and add in butter and parmesan cheese. Use a bar muddler to press the cheese(s) and butter into the pesto. This should be really easy especially if the butter is softened as noted above.
    2-3 T softened butter, ½ cup Romano cheese
  • Toss with hot pasta. Add pasta water as needed to make a thinner sauce as desired. Serve with parmesan.

Notes

A super easy pesto to use in chicken pesto flatbread or spread on a pressed brick Italian sandwich!
Storage Suggestions and Tips
  • Refrigerate in an airtight container with a lid for up to 4 days.
  • Freeze small portions in ice cube trays (Souper Cubes are awesome too!) so you can have pesto all year long.
  • Defrost in the fridge or at room temperature and stir to blend before using.
Substitution Ideas for Nuts and Greens in Pesto
  • Use roasted and salted sunflower seeds in place of nuts. Pistachios make great pesto as well!
  • Other herbs or green  to use in pesto are spinach, kale (stems removed) and arugula.
To keep pesto from turning black:
  • Never heat pesto directly on the stove. Heat isn’t pesto’s friend. Toss cold or room temperature fresh pesto with hot pasta.
  • Limit pesto’s exposure to air by either using immediately or storing covered in an airtight container.
  • Press a layer of plastic wrap directly on top of pesto before covering with an airtight, hard lid.
  • Freeze as soon as possible if freezing is your intention.
Course: Appetizer, Main Course, Pasta, pasta side dish, Salad
Cuisine: Italian
Author: Lori Murphy
Did you make this recipe? Tag @josieandnina or tag #josieandnina!

Leave a Comment or Ask A Question

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.